Leaving Guyland (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Life] >> Relationships



Message


backrowbaptist -> Leaving Guyland (9/5/2008 7:41:24 PM)

Ladies, I posted this in the Men's and Twenties forums. I thought I'd get your reaction.
I'm a forty something ex-bachelor (married 1 year), not much different from the guys described here. I found love (and family) late in life, a lot of my friends in similar situations haven't. What do y'all think of this?
'Why I Am Leaving Guyland' - Newsweek
It's "booze o'clock" on a recent Thursday night on New York's Fire Island—a rolling, inexact hour when 10 vacationing guys decide to kick off their nightly binge. Between tequila shots and pulls of beer, the sun-baked twentysomethings roar on the deck of their rented beach house, sounding the depths of maledom: sexual conquests, mastery of fire ("I'll grill that potato salad") and escape from the monotony of girlfriends and work. "I like starting things," says one guy, as if to sum up his generation. "Then it gets boring."
http://www.newsweek.com/id/156372
Check out the comments, too.




stellaluna -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/5/2008 7:52:48 PM)

Are you asking us why we think men don't want to grow up? Because that's what that article amounts to.

quote:


They are less likely to read a newspaper, attend church, vote for president or believe that people are basically trustworthy, helpful and fair. Meanwhile, saddled with an average of $20,000 in student debt and reared with a sense of entitlement that stops them from taking any old job, the percentage of 26-year-olds living with their parents has nearly doubled since 1970, from 11 to 20 percent, according to economist Bob Schoeni's research with the Population Studies Center at the University of Michigan.

I rest my case.




backrowbaptist -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/5/2008 11:10:58 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: stellaluna

Are you asking us why we think men don't want to grow up? Because that's what that article amounts to.

quote:


They are less likely to read a newspaper, attend church, vote for president or believe that people are basically trustworthy, helpful and fair. Meanwhile, saddled with an average of $20,000 in student debt and reared with a sense of entitlement that stops them from taking any old job, the percentage of 26-year-olds living with their parents has nearly doubled since 1970, from 11 to 20 percent, according to economist Bob Schoeni's research with the Population Studies Center at the University of Michigan.

I rest my case.

Just want reactions, stella (from previous posts, I suppose I could have guessed yours).
This doesn't trouble you? Did you read some of the comments at the end of the article? What will happen to our society if men check out of their responsibilities?




car2ner -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/6/2008 9:14:09 AM)

Sheesh, guys get away with being irresponsible because their parents let them. And their girlfriends let them. And they let themselves. I guess these guys are in for a dozy of a mid-life crisis!




stellaluna -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/6/2008 9:34:05 AM)

And by your previous posts one could surmise that you want to blame a man's lack of responsibility on everyone but the man. [;)]

I hold that people are responsible for themselves, regardless of age or gender. (True children excepted, of course.) If these men are miserable in their Peter Pan fantasy and too stupid to realize why, there is nothing that any of us can do to "fix" them.

quote:


If only all the posturing paid off. College guys believe that 80 percent of their friends are getting laid each weekend, says Kimmel, whose survey of 13,000 kids, mostly 18 to 22 years old, puts the actual figure at closer to 10 percent. After college, he says, the percentages merely get worse.

First of all, they are seriously disillusioned. Second of all, the fact that the magazine calls 18-22 year olds "kids" is a good part of the problem. They aren't men.




Auben -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/6/2008 11:20:32 AM)

I don't think women are as surprised by this are you are, backrowbaptist.




solo_soprano22 -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/6/2008 1:12:03 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Auben

I don't think women are as surprised by this are you are, backrowbaptist.


For real. [;)]




rgod -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/6/2008 5:46:49 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: backrowbaptist

Ladies, I posted this in the Men's and Twenties forums. I thought I'd get your reaction.
I'm a forty something ex-bachelor (married 1 year), not much different from the guys described here. I found love (and family) late in life, a lot of my friends in similar situations haven't. What do y'all think of this?
'Why I Am Leaving Guyland' - Newsweek
It's "booze o'clock" on a recent Thursday night on New York's Fire Island—a rolling, inexact hour when 10 vacationing guys decide to kick off their nightly binge. Between tequila shots and pulls of beer, the sun-baked twentysomethings roar on the deck of their rented beach house, sounding the depths of maledom: sexual conquests, mastery of fire ("I'll grill that potato salad") and escape from the monotony of girlfriends and work. "I like starting things," says one guy, as if to sum up his generation. "Then it gets boring."
http://www.newsweek.com/id/156372
Check out the comments, too.


This is not surprising in the least. In fact, the wise woman who wants to get married would do well to avoid men who are in these immature stages like the plague. Fortunately, many men grow out of it - some only when the meet the right woman, some right before they meet the right woman. Of these, many move on to be married and some are happily single (because they are called to be single - but they still grow out of this stage of development).




backrowbaptist -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/6/2008 6:00:53 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: stellaluna

And by your previous posts one could surmise that you want to blame a man's lack of responsibility on everyone but the man. [;)]

No Stella, I was the one in the other posts trying to get away from blaming and on to dealing with causes and solutions. I never blamed, just put forth the problem, which I'm doing now. If men are to take responsibilty and own up to this issue, should we not include women in the solution? Do you have no stake or interest in seeing Christian men, or men in general, embrace manhood over adolescence?

quote:

I hold that people are responsible for themselves, regardless of age or gender. (True children excepted, of course.) If these men are miserable in their Peter Pan fantasy and too stupid to realize why, there is nothing that any of us can do to "fix" them.


Is it up to women to 'fix' us? If in your opinion men are stupid and the problem is hopeless, then does the church (and society) just go on without them? Christianity becomes a female-dominated faith? Is that a consensus opinion in this forum? If so, that's useful input.




stellaluna -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/6/2008 6:10:07 PM)

You're just so worried that women are taking over Christianity you can't seem to hold your fellow men (as a gender) accountable for anything.

What I said was:
quote:


If these (referring to the men in the article) men are miserable in their Peter Pan fantasy and too stupid to realize why, there is nothing that any of us can do to "fix" them.

Males who persist in their childhood have two options: grow up or don't (and apparently be miserable).

I didn't say men are stupid. In fact, I know so much better than that, as I know dozens and dozens of stand-up guys. But guess what? They're busy living their lives: working hard, going to school, going to church, being husbands and fathers and even--shockingly--being single. The males spoken of in the article are perpetual little boys, not men.

Let me quote the article again and emphasize some things I find interesting:
quote:


They are less likely to read a newspaper, attend church, vote for president or believe that people are basically trustworthy, helpful and fair. Meanwhile, saddled with an average of $20,000 in student debt and reared with a sense of entitlement that stops them from taking any old job, the percentage of 26-year-olds living with their parents has nearly doubled since 1970, from 11 to 20 percent, according to economist Bob Schoeni's research with the Population Studies Center at the University of Michigan.

Frankly their parents should kick them out.

And don't feel bad, you should hear what I have to say about women that never grow up. [:D]




backrowbaptist -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/6/2008 6:15:01 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Auben

I don't think women are as surprised by this are you are, backrowbaptist.

Oh, I'm not surprised by this at all, Auben. I was one of the original Peter Pans. Like I said, I only recently got married and became a step-father, after thinking it was way too late for me. My road to responsible adulthood was long and filled with regretable decisions. That's why this issue is so important to me. As I stated in the OP, many of my forty-something single friends are still mired in this (married men, too), and I see more and more younger men making the same mistakes. This is a HUGE problem in the church, and I can imagine God's heart breaking over it. Some men are owning up to it and ministries are growing up everywhere to try to deal with the issue. Some are on the mark with what they want to do, some aren't. There is a LOT of resistance from Christian women, but a LOT of support, also. I've made it part of my ministry goals and commitments, so like I said, input on the problem is helpful.




backrowbaptist -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/6/2008 6:21:50 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: stellaluna

You're just so worried that women are taking over Christianity you can't seem to hold your fellow men (as a gender) accountable for anything.

Not true. When did I say men weren't accountable for this? And yes, I do fear women 'taking over' Christianity. From what I see in the Word, I don't think it's God's plan. Or at least not because the men have wimped out.


quote:

Frankly their parents should kick them out.

Amen, sister! Now we're getting somewhere. Question - have any of you done this?

quote:

And don't feel bad, you should hear what I have to say about women that never grow up. [:D]

I'm listening...




rgod -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/6/2008 8:53:02 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: backrowbaptist

quote:

ORIGINAL: Auben

I don't think women are as surprised by this are you are, backrowbaptist.

Oh, I'm not surprised by this at all, Auben. I was one of the original Peter Pans. Like I said, I only recently got married and became a step-father, after thinking it was way too late for me. My road to responsible adulthood was long and filled with regretable decisions. That's why this issue is so important to me. As I stated in the OP, many of my forty-something single friends are still mired in this (married men, too), and I see more and more younger men making the same mistakes. This is a HUGE problem in the church, and I can imagine God's heart breaking over it. Some men are owning up to it and ministries are growing up everywhere to try to deal with the issue. Some are on the mark with what they want to do, some aren't. There is a LOT of resistance from Christian women, but a LOT of support, also. I've made it part of my ministry goals and commitments, so like I said, input on the problem is helpful.


Wow - your statement is fascinating. Let me ask you - what made you want to change? Was it meeting the "right" woman for you - was it a restlessness inside - or something else? And in what ways are Christian women resisting? Also, can you share some concrete ways in which women can be supportive? I think for myself and many other Christian women, Peter Pan guys are kind of annoying because they kind of waste your time - you know? But that is probably not the right attitude to have since we are supposed to love one another? Also, why did you remain in that "Peter Pan" phase? Why do other men? I hope I'm not asking too many questions here - I don't want to hijack your thread ...




car2ner -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/7/2008 2:22:31 PM)

quote:

Frankly their parents should kick them out.


Amen, sister! Now we're getting somewhere. Question - have any of you done this?


Kinda sorta. Our guys are good guys but when we moved we told them that they weren't coming with us. They had about a year to prepare. Human nature being what it is, they did very little to get ready to be on their own. Have to let you know that my in-law did the same thing with their daughters.




backrowbaptist -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/7/2008 10:55:31 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: rgod

Wow - your statement is fascinating. Let me ask you - what made you want to change? Was it meeting the "right" woman for you - was it a restlessness inside - or something else? And in what ways are Christian women resisting? Also, can you share some concrete ways in which women can be supportive? I think for myself and many other Christian women, Peter Pan guys are kind of annoying because they kind of waste your time - you know? But that is probably not the right attitude to have since we are supposed to love one another? Also, why did you remain in that "Peter Pan" phase? Why do other men? I hope I'm not asking too many questions here - I don't want to hijack your thread ...

I can’t say any one thing made me want to change. It was more a maturing over time. I had always wanted to marry, but kept putting it off until (I thought) it was too late. A lot of it had to do with being too picky, in a typically shallow way. This girls legs were too skinny, I didn’t like that one’s laugh, she’s not athletic enough, or whatever. But, I’ve got to say, a lot of women I did like felt similar things about me. What it really stemmed from was a couple of relationships in college that I was naïve and immature in pursuing. They ended badly, and I think I used them to rationalize not getting serious, mostly out of fear. With a lot of guys it’s fear. Fear of intimacy or fear of failure. I think a lot of guys prolong their adolescence so long that they don’t think they have the ability, or maturity, to be a responsible husband and father.

NOTE - If you would like to hear the rest of this story, I posted it in my blog "The View From the Back Pew", in BlogTowne. Hope you don't mind, rgod, but I quoted your post
http://forums.crosswalk.com/pgdrewrite.aspx?404;http://forums.crosswalk.com:80/Leaving_Guyland/m_3780299/mpage_1/tm.htm




Kath -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/8/2008 1:35:41 AM)

moving from She Says to Relationships, closing duplicate threads.

Sincerely
Kath

Please do not comment on this action in the community or send me a PM about it. If you have questions, comments or concerns please email Fritz at community@salemwebnetwork.com allowing time for a reply. Thanks!




deermousie -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/8/2008 10:04:58 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: stellaluna
I know dozens and dozens of stand-up guys. But guess what? They're busy living their lives: working hard, going to school, going to church, being husbands and fathers and even--shockingly--being single. The males spoken of in the article are perpetual little boys, not men.


This.

This is simplistic but the broad brushstrokes hold: there are people who are living to please God for life, and people who are trying to please themselves (sometimes at the expense of others) on a minute-to-minute basis.

I think that people doing it right are going to get an education, get a job, get married and have kids. They'll live honestly and be givers.

I think people not doing it right will just try to please themselves at the moment and may rage against how unfair life is because they what they want doesn't come floating down from heaven and land at their feet. They will be takers.

God says a man should support his own family (1 Tim. 5:8); pleasure seekers are happy to be supported.

God says sex is for marriage; godless men want to fulfill their desires of the moment.

Children are to be raised in a marriage; godless men don't care about resulting children and see them as something to be discarded.

Wives are to be loved and lived with in an understanding way; godless men see them as a source (kinda like a vending machine).

Yeah, we see women like this, too, unfortunately. Sin is an equal opportunity "employer." And an equal opportunity destroyer.




SuccessinTruth -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/8/2008 3:35:38 PM)

Let's face it folks, "we war not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of darkness in this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places". Ephesians 6:12 Not completely in context, I'll admit, but our culture holds no answers, it is the problem. With what the schools teach, the sociologists, the courts, the psychobabble, the labels that are put on everyone so that they can blame their label instead of taking responsibility for their behaviour, this society is too busy providing excuses to provide solutions. Including the one that some churches provide, "demon possession". It's not my fault, God, the devil made me do it.
What we can do is what the Scripture tells us to do:
Do not be deceived
Pray
Raise up a child in the way that he should go
Pray
Spread the Gospel
Pray
Trust in the Lord
Pray




rgod -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/8/2008 4:15:15 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: deermousie
I think that people doing it right are going to get an education, get a job, get married and have kids. They'll live honestly and be givers.


Deermousie - I agree with you on most of the points except for the one quoted above. Some are called to be single and to not be parents. Not everyone is called to get married and have kids. But, I also think that you perceptively identified that a man can be a "peter pan" boy and also be married. It is this type of man who treats his wife as a vending machine (very interesting way of putting this - and very accurate) or doesn't want to care for his family.

quote:


I can’t say any one thing made me want to change. It was more a maturing over time. I had always wanted to marry, but kept putting it off until (I thought) it was too late. A lot of it had to do with being too picky, in a typically shallow way. This girls legs were too skinny, I didn’t like that one’s laugh, she’s not athletic enough, or whatever. But, I’ve got to say, a lot of women I did like felt similar things about me. What it really stemmed from was a couple of relationships in college that I was naïve and immature in pursuing. They ended badly, and I think I used them to rationalize not getting serious, mostly out of fear. With a lot of guys it’s fear. Fear of intimacy or fear of failure. I think a lot of guys prolong their adolescence so long that they don’t think they have the ability, or maturity, to be a responsible husband and father.

NOTE - If you would like to hear the rest of this story, I posted it in my blog "The View From the Back Pew", in BlogTowne. Hope you don't mind, rgod, but I quoted your post
http://forums.crosswalk.com/pgdrewrite.aspx?404;http://forums.crosswalk.com:80/Leaving_Guyland/m_3780299/mpage_1/tm.htm


No problem with quoting me. I read your blog - it gave me some good insight. I thought it is interesting to note that you talk about being afraid. I think that sometimes I, as a woman, forget that a man can be scared or scarred emotionally - because they seem to bounce back from things so quickly - or because they express their emotions differently. This is an important point, because it is at the root of some of the selfish behavior - and it helps me to see these men more compassionately.

But for me, as a woman who would definitely get married if she met the right man, it all boils down to using wisdom. If I meet a Peter Pan man, I don't let my heart get involved with him or continue to see him once my suspicions are confirmed. While I can sympathize with him and pray that he'll mature in this area, I'm not going to be the woman who hangs around for 7 years, waiting for him to grow up. And, to be frank, if a woman does what the bible says in terms of unmarried relationships with the opposite sex, a lot of those Peter Pan men tend to fade away because there's always some other woman who doesn't mind doing what she won't. [;)] (There are exceptions ... but we need to be real on this point.)

So Backrowbaptist - you mentioned that you felt that God's heart was breaking over this issue. Have you thought about helping other men who struggle with this? If so, what are some things that you are thinking about doing?




backrowbaptist -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/9/2008 1:20:49 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: rgod

No problem with quoting me. I read your blog - it gave me some good insight. I thought it is interesting to note that you talk about being afraid. I think that sometimes I, as a woman, forget that a man can be scared or scarred emotionally - because they seem to bounce back from things so quickly - or because they express their emotions differently. This is an important point, because it is at the root of some of the selfish behavior - and it helps me to see these men more compassionately.
But for me, as a woman who would definitely get married if she met the right man, it all boils down to using wisdom. If I meet a Peter Pan man, I don't let my heart get involved with him or continue to see him once my suspicions are confirmed. While I can sympathize with him and pray that he'll mature in this area, I'm not going to be the woman who hangs around for 7 years, waiting for him to grow up. And, to be frank, if a woman does what the bible says in terms of unmarried relationships with the opposite sex, a lot of those Peter Pan men tend to fade away because there's always some other woman who doesn't mind doing what she won't. [;)] (There are exceptions ... but we need to be real on this point.)
So Backrowbaptist - you mentioned that you felt that God's heart was breaking over this issue. Have you thought about helping other men who struggle with this? If so, what are some things that you are thinking about doing?

Yes, as I said, I've commited some of my ministry goals to working with men dealing with this issue. At my new church, I brought up the subject to out family minister, and he's taken off with it. We just last night had a Monday Night Football men-only get together, and we're looking to start a bible study, probably tied to some kind of service ministry that will hopefully lead to building a men's ministry, God willing.
I've also commited to helping out the Boy Scouts (my step-son is a Weeblo). They do so much to build up boys toward manhood, and have been under such an attack for standing firm in their principles.




Kat_D -> RE: Leaving Guyland (9/9/2008 3:34:24 PM)

quote:

It's "booze o'clock" on a recent Thursday night on New York's Fire Island


Gee, who knew? I always thought the majority of the men who hung out on Fire Island liked... well, guys! That's why they call it Gauyland.[sm=unsure.gif]




Page: [1]



Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.5 ANSI